DUSTED MAGAZINE

Dusted Reviews

V/A - Natural Selection

today features
reviews charts
labels writers
info donate

Search by Artist



Sign up here to receive weekly updates from Dusted


email address

Recent Reviews

Jason Ajemian's Smokeless Heat - The Art of Dying

Matt Bauer - The Island Moved in the Storm

Harold Budd and Clive Wright - A Song for Lost Blossoms

Burning Star Core - Challenger

Circle X - Prehistory

Crystal Antlers - Crystal Antlers

Deerhoof - Offend Maggie

Fucked Up - The Chemistry of Common Life

Morgan Geist - Double Night Time

Gilberto Gil - Gilberto Gil (Frevo Rasgado) / Gilberto Gil (Cérebro Eletrônico) / Expresso 2222

Grails - Doomsdayer’s Holiday

Group Inerane - Guitars from Agadez (Music of Niger)

Roy Harper - Stormcock

Roy Harper - Flat Baroque and Berserk

Roy Harper - Whatever Happened to Jugula?

Jackie O Motherfucker - Freedomland

John Phillips - Pussycat

Lambchop - OH (ohio)

Charlie Louvin - Steps to Heaven

Alex Moulton - Exodus

Mount Eerie with Julie Doiron & Fred Squire - Lost Wisdom

Of Montreal - Skeletal Lamping

Orange - In the Midst of Chaos

Benoit Pioulard - Temper

Quintron - Too Thirsty 4 Love

Religious Knives - The Door

The Replacements - Tim / Pleased to Meet Me / Don’t Tell a Soul / All Shook Down

Marnie Stern - This Is It and I Am It and You Are It and So Is That and He Is It and She Is It and It Is It and That Is That

Sun Ra - Sleeping Beauty

V/A - Eccentric Soul: The Young Disciples

V/A - Where’s the Beat? Live in the WFMU Studios

Yo Majesty - Futuristically Speaking: Never Be Afraid

Yoro Sidibe - Yoro Sidibe

Dusted Reviews


Artist: V/A

Album: Natural Selection

Label: Nature Sounds

Review date: Mar. 19, 2006


This is a release designed to build a healthy appetite for the Brooklyn based Nature Sounds label’s 2006 release schedule. The major problem with this is that the album appears geared towards representing the Wu-Tang in 2006, rather than solid quality hip-hop; eight of the compilation’s twelve tracks feature members or affiliates. Considering the fragmented nature of the Clan’s public profile and the recent redundancy of most of its member’s solo work, this is a courageous move.

Masta Killa, recent PETA cover star and Wu standard bearer, initiates the LP with "Ringin' Bells," which sees him sermonizing over a dull soul loop courtesy of old school Wu revivalist Bronze Nazareth. While his words and metaphors aren’t overly complex here, his basic but lengthy flow still requires a few listens before it becomes easy to settle into his scholarly approach. The increasingly weary presence of Raekwon wastes a smooth funk production job and buoyant hook on Pete Rock’s “The PJ’s”; he becomes as complacent and utterly boring as a million other New York MCs on the archetypal hustler sound of “Guerilla Rap.” Raekwon is best when he’s furiously arrogant, wrapping imaginary phrases around street hustling narratives. He seems to have forgotten the storytelling tag-team chemistry of his work with the now universally adored Ghostface.

This release's selling point and predictable highlight is further fruit from Ghostface’s collaborations with MF Doom, a b-side from the forthcoming LP called “Angeles.” The music comes cut straight from a Bernard Herrmann and Bacharach TV show theme and both MCs seem to be on the same lyrical page, telling conversational tales of avenging angels (the ‘Charlie’s’ variety). As for the affiliates, Wu producer Mathematics drops an untitled and inconsequential instrumental, while Killah Priest comes more from the Miami streets than the heart of Brooklyn as part of the thug/preacher Black Market Militia clique.

The poor showing from the East Coast leaves Xzibit’s West Coast ‘super group’ Strong Arm Steady clique offer up two reasonably rocking tracks, the Krondon-led and smurf-chorused “Gold Chain Music" and shiny grime of "You ain't me." Xzibit and Ras Kass show glimpses of their fiercer youth on the latter, while Chamillionaire does a Nate Dogg impersonation on the song’s poppy hook.

The closest thing to a commercially viable (and club bumpable) cut here comes from the three man pile-up of Psycho Les, Al Tariq & Problemz on "Stick Up.” All three spit funny, tight and smart-arsed rhymes with knowledgeable hip-hop bites, each seemingly aware of the others strong verses; its only real fault lies in the generic “jump / hands in the air” chorus. This is the kind of thrusting horn beat that MOP can be found bellowing all over causing stampedes from club land to billboard.

Perhaps without the prevalence of Wu-Tang acts on Natural Selection, it could’ve been a more varied release, taking tracks from different corners of the hip-hop experience. But as this compilation is built on the crumbling (if not now almost fully decrepit) foundations of that now defunct empire, it's not a surprise that it doesn't spark lasting interest.

By Scott McKeating

Read More

View all articles by Scott McKeating

Find out more about Nature Sounds

delicious digg google newsvine Technorati [Slashdot] [Reddit] [Facebook] [StumbleUpon]

©2002-2005 Dusted Magazine. All Rights Reserved.